Weekend Trips From NYC: What Each One Really Costs
These weekend trips from NYC are ranked by what a night actually costs, not by how nice the photos look. Five places are within 82 to 159 miles of Manhattan: Philadelphia, the Hudson Valley, the Poconos, the Catskills and Cape May. Philadelphia is the cheapest, with a median weekend night of $114 for a 3-star or better hotel in January. A FlixBus there starts at $23.98 and takes 1 hour 40 minutes. Below you get the car-free route, the gas bill and the cheapest month for each place, then five more trips from NYC. The same numbers for 16 places across the country are on the cheap weekend trips by month page.
Weekend hotel rates from New York, month by month
Median nightly rate of 3-star+ hotels for a Friday to Sunday stay. The circled rate is each place's cheapest month.
| Destination | December | January | February | March | April | May | June | July | August | September | October |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Philadelphia | $122 | $114 | $123 | $125 | $140 | $203 | $207 | $191 | $148 | $155 | $143 |
| Lancaster | $116 | $126 | $139 | $182 | $145 | $179 | $190 | $194 | $174 | $212 | $121 |
| Boston | $136 | $110 | $162 | $178 | $215 | $323 | $311 | $286 | $333 | $251 | $162 |
| Newport | $216 | $153 | $187 | $187 | $248 | $459 | $574 | $688 | $725 | $567 | $209 |
| Poconos | $234 | $189 | $330 | $181 | $202 | $243 | $265 | $314 | $402 | $280 | $349 |
| Cape May | $370 | $255 | $239 | $268 | $304 | $299 | $561 | $662 | $738 | $404 | $218 |
| Catskills | $258 | $323 | $341 | $323 | $312 | $374 | $733 | $366 | $448 | $412 | $264 |
| Hudson Valley | $296 | $354 | $351 | $300 | $312 | $318 | $373 | $529 | $405 | $471 | $284 |
Getting there from New York, and the weekend for two
| To | Drive | Gas, round trip | Without a car | Weekend for two, cheapest month |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Philadelphia | 2h 06m · 96 mi | $32 | FlixBus, 1h 40m, from $24 | $260 January |
| Lancaster | 3h 24m · 166 mi | $55 | – | $287 December |
| Boston | 4h 36m · 210 mi | $70 | FlixBus, 3 hours 55 minutes, from $45 | $290 January |
| Newport | 4h · 177 mi | $59 | – | $365 January |
| Poconos | 1h 54m · 87 mi | $29 | – | $391 March |
| Cape May | 3h 18m · 159 mi | $53 | – | $489 October |
| Catskills | 2h 24m · 111 mi | $37 | – | $553 December |
| Hudson Valley | 1h 48m · 82 mi | $27 | – | $595 October |
Weekend for two = 2 nights at the month's median 3-star+ rate plus the cheapest way there and back for two (bus or train fare × 4, or gas at 25 mpg and the AAA state average, whichever is lower).
What is the cheapest weekend trip from NYC?
Philadelphia wins on every number that matters. Its median weekend night in a 3-star or better hotel runs $114 in January, $122 in December and $123 in February. The median is for a Friday and Saturday night for two adults. It stays under $150 until April and tops out at $207 in June.
The Poconos come next at $181 in March and $189 in January. The Catskills sit at $258 in December and $264 in October. Cape May is cheap only at the edges of summer: $218 in October, $239 in February, against $738 in August. The Hudson Valley has no month under $284.
The drive is short for all of them. Philadelphia is 96 miles (2.1 hours), the Hudson Valley 82 miles (1.8 hours), the Poconos 87 miles (1.9 hours), the Catskills 111 miles (2.4 hours) and Cape May 159 miles (3.3 hours). Distance matters less than the hotel line. The drive to Cape May costs about $26 more in gas than the drive to the Hudson Valley, but a summer weekend there costs hundreds more in rooms.
Which weekend trips from NYC work without a car?
Two of the five work well without a car and two work in part.
Philadelphia: yes. FlixBus leaves Port Authority and other Manhattan stops, takes 1 hour 40 minutes at its fastest and starts at $23.98. Amtrak's Northeast Regional and Acela run from Moynihan Train Hall to 30th Street Station. Amtrak shows its fare only at booking.
Hudson Valley: partly. Metro-North's Hudson Line to Poughkeepsie (Zone 9) costs $21.00 one way off peak, which includes weekends, and $28.25 at weekday peak. Beacon and Hudson are walkable from the station. Farms and wineries are not.
Catskills: partly. Trailways of New York runs from Port Authority to Kingston in 2 hours 10 minutes from $34.65, and to Woodstock in 2 hours 56 minutes from $39. Both towns are walkable. Trailheads, Hunter and Windham need a car or a taxi.
Poconos and Cape May: plan on a car. Buses reach park-and-ride lots at the edge of the Poconos, and current service could not be confirmed. For Cape May, no direct NYC service is confirmed. NJ Transit runs routes 313 and 316 from Philadelphia, and the seasonal 316 excursion is $37.95 round trip.
What does gas cost for a weekend trip from NYC?
Gas is the smaller part of a driving weekend, but it is easy to price. The math uses the round trip, a 25 mpg car and the AAA price for New York of $4.14 a gallon.
- Hudson Valley: 164 miles round trip, about $27
- Poconos: 174 miles, about $29
- Philadelphia: 192 miles, about $32
- Catskills: 222 miles, about $37
- Cape May: 318 miles, about $53
Tolls, parking and a Manhattan garage are extra. In Philadelphia, a car is a cost, not a help: the bus and train both end in Center City, where the big sights are close together. For the Hudson Valley and Catskills, one rental or your own car makes sense only if you plan farms, hikes or ski slopes. Otherwise the train or bus to a walkable town and one taxi leg often costs less than a tank plus parking.
Is Philadelphia a good weekend trip from NYC?

It is the best value on the list and the easiest to do without a car. Rooms stay between $114 and $143 on a weekend from December through April and again in October. May to July is the high stretch at $191 to $207.
A Sunday night is cheaper still in the busy months: $141 instead of $203 in May, $119 instead of $207 in June. If you can leave Monday morning, you save about $60 a night.
The city is about walking. The paid tours with the most reviews are the Dark Philly Adult Night Tour at $38 (4.9 from 4,681 reviews), Revolution and the Founders: History Tour of Philadelphia at $29 (4.9 from 4,010) and the Philadelphia Old City Historic Walking Tour at $43.50 (4.9 from 2,486). The full plan, with free things and where to stay, is on the Philadelphia weekend page.
Is the Hudson Valley worth it for a weekend?

It is the closest of the five at 82 miles, and the only one with a $21 train fare, but it is not cheap to sleep there. The median weekend night is $284 in October, $296 in December and $300 in March. It reaches $529 in July and $471 in September.
The Sunday-night trick is weaker here than elsewhere. In January, the median Sunday night ($431) is higher than the weekend night ($354), so book by the date, not by a rule. In April the Sunday figure is $224 against $312 on the weekend.
Best value: take Metro-North off peak, stay in a walkable river town such as Beacon or Hudson, and pick a shoulder month. See the Hudson Valley page for the rate strip and the plan.
What does a Catskills weekend cost in each month?

The Catskills are 111 miles from Manhattan, a 2.4 hour drive. A weekend night runs $258 in December and $264 in October, with $312 to $323 from January to April. June jumps to $733, the highest in the Catskills by a wide margin.
Sunday nights fall hard outside summer. January drops from $323 to $138 and April from $312 to $148. That is the cheapest trick on this page: a Friday or Saturday check-in, with a Sunday night added, brings the average well below the weekend median.
The bus helps only for the towns. Trailways reaches Kingston from $34.65 and Woodstock from $39. A paid add-on that suits a weekend is the Llama/Alpaca Hike and Farm Tour at $70.61 per person (4.8 from 126 reviews). The Catskills page has the rest.
Are the Poconos a cheap weekend trip from NYC?

They can be. The median weekend night is $181 in March, $189 in January and $202 in April. That is the second-lowest of the five. It climbs above $300 in July, August and October ($314, $402 and $349) and hits $330 in February.
The Poconos are the weakest car-free trip. The carrier page for Port Authority to Mount Pocono showed no schedules when checked, and buses that do run stop at park-and-ride lots outside the resort areas. Gas for the 174 mile round trip is about $29.
Sunday nights help in December, when $138 replaces $234, and in July, when $247 replaces $314. The Poconos page has every month.
When is Cape May cheap, and when is it not?

Cape May has the widest price swing of any place on this page. A weekend night is $218 in October, $239 in February, $255 in January and $268 in March. In June it is $561, in July $662 and in August $738.
The Sunday-night discount is large off season: $218 instead of $370 in December and $177 instead of $239 in February. In July and August it nearly disappears ($617 and $565).
On the water, the 2-Hour Sunset Safari Eco Cruise on the Osprey is $40 (4.9 from 240 reviews), and Dolphin Watching around Cape May is $45 (4.7 from 69). Getting there is the catch: it is 159 miles and 3.3 hours by road, and no direct NYC transit is confirmed. The Cape May page covers the month choice in full.
How much does a weekend trip from NYC cost for two?
Use one simple formula: two weekend nights at the median rate, plus gas for the round trip. It leaves out food, tours and parking, and it uses each place's cheapest month.
- Philadelphia in January: 2 x $114 + $32 gas = $260
- Poconos in March: 2 x $181 + $29 = $391
- Cape May in October: 2 x $218 + $53 = $489
- Catskills in December: 2 x $258 + $37 = $553
- Hudson Valley in October: 2 x $284 + $27 = $595
The hotel is the number that moves. Gas ranges from $27 to $53 across all five. A room for two nights in Philadelphia ($228) costs less than a single night in Cape May in August ($738).
A car-free Philadelphia trip swaps the gas for two bus tickets. FlixBus advertises $23.98 as a from fare and it moves by date, so check the day you travel. Rooms are for two adults, so the hotel figure is the same for a couple or two friends sharing.
Does a Sunday night really save money on a trip from NYC?
Often, but not everywhere. The median Sunday night for a 3-star or better hotel is lower than the weekend night in most of these places most months.
- Catskills: $138 in December and January against $258 and $323
- Cape May: $218 in December and $177 in February against $370 and $239
- Poconos: $138 in December against $234
- Philadelphia: $97 in December against $122, and $119 in June against $207
But in the Hudson Valley the Sunday night in January is $431, above the $354 weekend night. Cape May's Sunday night in October ($234) and the Poconos in March ($220) are also above the weekend rate.
The practical rule: for a three-night trip, check in Friday and leave Monday, and price the Sunday night separately. In the Catskills and Cape May it can save more than a meal out, and the saving is bigger than any gas decision you make.
Should you pick the beach, the mountains or the city?
Pick by season, because the price gaps follow the weather.
City: Philadelphia. Lowest and flattest rates, between $114 and $207 in every month on this page. It works in any month, including winter, and needs no car.
Beach: Cape May. October and February are the only months under $240. If you want a swim, you pay the August price of $738. For a walk on the beach and a boat trip, October is the better deal.
Mountains: Catskills and Poconos. The Poconos are cheaper in the cold months and the shoulder, from $181 to $202 in March and April. The Catskills run $258 to $374 from December to May, then jump to $733 in June. Both are car-first.
River towns: Hudson Valley. The only one of the five reachable by commuter rail, from $21.00 off peak. Rooms run $284 to $529, so the train fare is small next to the hotel.
Which month is cheapest for a weekend trip from NYC?
There is no single answer, because each place has its own low:
- Philadelphia: January, $114
- Poconos: March, $181
- Catskills: December, $258
- Cape May: October, $218
- Hudson Valley: October, $284
For a winter weekend in December, Philadelphia at $122 and the Poconos at $234 are the cheapest. In the spring shoulder, March and April keep Philadelphia at $125 to $140 and the Poconos at $181 to $202. In summer, Philadelphia ($191 to $207 in May to July) is the only one of the five that stays under $300 on a weekend. In fall, Cape May drops to $218 in October while Philadelphia holds at $143.
A tip for any month: ask for the Sunday night. In the Catskills, Poconos and Cape May it is cheaper by $60 to $185 in the cold months.
More weekends from New York
Boston, MA
Amtrak's Northeast Regional serves both Boston South Station and Back Bay from New York. The Amtrak route page prints no fare or New York to Boston time, so price it at booking. One free thing: the Freedom Trail sites run by the National Park Service, including Faneuil Hall's visitor center, Bunker Hill Monument and the USS Constitution, carry free admission. The Old State House, Paul Revere House and Old North Church charge.
Source: Amtrak Northeast Regional, National Park Service, Boston National Historical Park
Mystic, CT
Mystic has its own Amtrak stop (MYS), so the trip works without a car. The headline sights are Mystic Seaport, a living history village with the Charles W. Morgan whaleship, and Mystic Aquarium, which Visit Connecticut calls home to New England's only beluga whales. Free option: the drive along Route 169, a National Scenic Byway. The Amtrak and Connecticut pages print no fares, so check both before you book.
Source: Amtrak Northeast Regional, Visit Connecticut, Mystic
New Haven, CT
New Haven is on the same Amtrak Northeast Regional line, with stops at State Street Station and Union Station, so it is a car-free weekend out of Moynihan Train Hall. Amtrak prints no fare on its route page.
Source: Amtrak Northeast Regional
Fire Island, NY
Ferries cross from Bay Shore in about 30 minutes to a barrier island with no cars, with stops including Ocean Beach, Saltaire, Fair Harbor and Kismet. The park service charges no entrance fee at Fire Island National Seashore sites, so the beach itself is free once you are across. Ferry fares are on the operators' pages, and the NPS notes passenger ferries run from mid-May to mid-October.
Source: Fire Island Ferries, National Park Service, Fire Island National Seashore fees, National Park Service, Fire Island National Seashore
Montauk, NY
The Long Island Rail Road reaches Montauk, at the eastern tip of the island, from Penn Station in Manhattan, so the trip needs no car. The MTA page gives no Montauk fare or time. Look up both on the LIRR fares and schedules pages before you commit, as the ride is long and the trains thin out on winter weekends.
Source: MTA, Long Island Rail Road
Tours worth the weekend
-
Philadelphia · Ghost and night
Dark Philly Adult Night Tour
Check Availability -
Philadelphia · Walking and history
Revolution and the Founders: History Tour of Philadelphia
Check Availability -
Philadelphia · Walking and history
Philadelphia Old City Historic Walking Tour with 10+ Top Sites
Check Availability -
Lancaster · Walking and history
Premium Amish Country Tour including Amish Farm and House
Check Availability -
Lancaster · Walking and history
Amish Experience SuperSaver Package
Check Availability -
Lancaster · Walking and history
Unique Amish Immersion in Lancaster
Check Availability -
Boston · On the water
Boston Duck Boat Sightseeing City Tour with Cruise
Check Availability -
Boston · Walking and history
Boston: Freedom Trail History Small Group Walking Tour
Check Availability -
Boston · Trolley, bus or carriage
Boston Hop-On Hop-Off Trolley Tour with 11 Stops
Check Availability
Questions
What is the best weekend trip I can take from NYC?
For the lowest cost, Philadelphia: a median weekend hotel night of $114 in January and a $23.98 bus from Manhattan. For nature, the Catskills and for a beach, Cape May in October or February.
What is a cheap weekend getaway from NYC?
One with a median weekend night under $150 and a cheap way there. Philadelphia fits from December to April and in October. Add a Sunday night in the Catskills, Poconos or Cape May to cut the average sharply in the cold months.
Can I do a weekend trip from NYC without a car?
Yes. Philadelphia is the easiest by FlixBus or Amtrak. The Hudson Valley works by Metro-North from $21.00 off peak, and Kingston and Woodstock by Trailways from $34.65. The Poconos and Cape May need a car.
What are the best weekend trips from NYC by train?
Philadelphia, Boston, New Haven and Mystic by Amtrak, and the Hudson Valley by Metro-North. Amtrak shows fares only at booking, so compare it with the $23.98 FlixBus to Philadelphia.
Where can I go from NYC in December?
Philadelphia is cheapest at $122 a night on a weekend. The Poconos are $234, the Catskills $258 and the Hudson Valley $296. Cape May is $370 on a weekend but $218 on a Sunday night.
Sources: Amtrak Northeast Regional, FlixBus New York to Philadelphia, MTA Metro-North fare table, Trailways of New York, Kingston, Trailways of New York, Woodstock, NJ Transit bus fare charts, Martz Trailways, AAA gas prices, New York, National Park Service, Boston National Historical Park, Visit Connecticut, Mystic, Fire Island Ferries, National Park Service, Fire Island National Seashore, MTA, Long Island Rail Road, National Park Service, Fire Island National Seashore.